Judge: Susan Worst (Wood River High School)
Resolution: RESOLVED: The United States Federal Government should ban all testing that requires the use of animals.
|Click to begin|
Click on the other tabs to watch watch that speech.
Posted at N/A by Anca Dogaroiu
The Belmont Report:
Posted at N/A by Tim Keegan
Ack Botting and Adrian Morrison / 1997 / "Animal Research is Vital to Medicine" / http://www.indiana.edu/~acoustic/s685/Rowan-1997.pdf / (page 83)
This match has been completed. Show the Decision.
Submitted at N/A by Susan Worst
|Category||Anca Dogaroiu||Tim Keegan|
|Use of evidence:||3.3||4|
|Coherence of arguments:||2.8||4|
|Responsiveness to opponent:||3.5||3.9|
|Identification of key points:||3.7||4.5|
|Comments:||You have a fluid and relaxed speaking style, especially in your Constructive speech. Well done.
You ask me to assume early on that all lives are worth the same, but don't ever come back around to substantiating that, either through evidence or analytics. This is a problem that, for me, wasn't mitigated by your interesting and thoughtful comparisons to the Tuskegee study. If you had provided warrants in your first speech for your claim that human and animal lives are to be valued the same, it might have given you some ground to draw the comparison between research animals and the people in the study.
|Energetic delivery, though it was disappointing to have the discussion veer over into "Don't kill grandpa" territory.
You did resort to personal attack toward the end, starting a downward trend in the level of discourse. ALSO YOU WERE SHOUTING.
The decision is for the Opposition: Tim Keegan
Reason for Decision:
I vote for the opposition. The proposition's case was predicated entirely on the equal worth of every life, and that was never established through philosophy, evidence, or analytics. The opposition mitigates many of the harms caused by more frivolous examples of animal testing while stopping short of banning all of it. Not a perfect solution, but I judge it to be the best of the choices with which I am presented.
Thank you both for your participation, and enjoy the rest of your week.