Skip header content and main navigation Binghamton University, State University of New York - Patrick
Banner Brandon Evans Brittney Bleyle Trevor Reddick Phillip George Sonya Robinson Maneo Choudhury Daniel Friedman Joe Leeson-Schatz Anna Pinchuk Masakazu Kurihara Joshua Frumkin

Binghamton Speech & Debate

Proposition: Allana Spears (Colegio Bilingüe New Horizons) vs. Opposition: Zoella Lin (Lexington High School)

Judge: Brittney Bleyle (Austin Peay State University)

Resolution: Finals Week: This House Believes that Animal Testing Should be Banned.

  • Allana Spears
    Allana Spears
    vs.



    Zoella Lin
    Zoella Lin
    Click to begin

    Speech Details

    Click on the other tabs to watch watch that speech.

    Posted at May 19, 2020 01:07:44AM EST by Allana Spears

    Citations

    Show

    https://www.skepticalscience.com/renewable-energy-is-too-expensive.htm

    https://www.eesi.org/topics/fossil-fuels/description

    https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2017/09/climate-change-costs-us-economy-billions-report/

    https://www.nei.org/news/2018/cost-of-nuclear-generation-reaches-10-year-low

    Posted at May 19, 2020 11:52:54PM EST by Zoella Lin

    Citations

    Show

    Cites: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1hzoM8OFnGh_c4PtzwE76nm5hGVxUt0ns

    Posted at May 21, 2020 12:15:50AM EST by Allana Spears

    Citations

    Show

    Jacob Philip, March/2014, "GENERAL SITE SUITABILITY
    CRITERIA FOR NUCLEAR POWER STATIONS": https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1218/ML12188A053.pdf

    Rodney Adams, August/16/1996, "NUCLEAR POWER IN REMOTE AREAS": http://www.atomicengines.com/distributed.html

    n.d, 2018, "Fossil Fuels": https://www.eesi.org/topics/fossil-fuels/description


    THADDEUS SWANEK, November/6/2018, "Cost of Nuclear Generation Reaches Nearly 10-Year Low": https://www.nei.org/news/2018/cost-of-nuclear-generation-reaches-10-year-low

    KATHERINE BAGLEY, November/10/2016, "At Standing Rock, A Battle Over Fossil Fuels and Land": https://e360.yale.edu/features/at_standing_rock_battle_over_fossil_fuels_and_land

    Dallas Goldtooth, January/9/2015, "
    This article is more than 5 years old
    Keystone XL would destroy our native lands. This is why we fight": https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/09/keystone-xl-would-destroy-native-lands-we-fight

    Emily Cassidy, February/7/2019, "There Were 137 Oil Spills In The US In 2018. See Where They Happened.": https://blog.resourcewatch.org/2019/02/07/there-were-137-oil-spills-in-the-us-in-2018-see-where-they-happened/

    https://www.biologicaldiversity.org/programs/public_lands/energy/dirty_energy_development/oil_and_gas/gulf_oil_spill/pdfs/GulfWildlifeReport_2011.pdf

    Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, March/22/2012, "Severe nuclear reactor accidents likely every 10 to 20 years, European study suggests": https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/05/120522134942.htm


    Achenbach, J. and D.A. Fahrenthold. 2010. Oil spill dumped 4.9 million barrels into Gulf of
    Mexico, latest measure shows. Washington Post, August 3, 2010. Available at:
    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/08/02/AR2010080204695.html

    Alcoforado Santos, C., L. Simoes Novaes, and L. Carvalho Gomes. 2010. Genotoxic effects of
    the diesel water-soluble fraction on the seahorse Hippocampus reidi (Teleostei: Syngnathidae)
    during acute exposure. Zoologia 27(6):956-960.

    Anderson, B. A., D. Arenella-Parkerson, B. M. Phillips, R. S. Tjeerdema, and D. Crane. 2009.
    Preliminary investigation of the effects of dispersed Prudhoe Bay Crude Oil on developing
    topsmelt embryos, Atherinops affinis. Environmental Pollution 157:1058-1061.

    Associated Press. 2010. Oil Hits La.'s Largest Seabird Nesting Area: Wildlife Toll Mounts In
    Gulf As Oil Hits Louisiana's Largest Seabird Nesting Ground. July 15, 2010. Available at:
    http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/07/14/national/main6679576.shtml

    Barron, M.G., M.G. Carls, J.W. Short, and S.D. Rice. 2003. Photoenhanced toxicity of aqueous
    phase and chemically dispersed weathered Alaska North Slope crude oil to Pacific herring eggs
    and larvae. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 22(3): 650–660.

    Bernanke, J., and H.R. Kohler. 2009. The impact of environmental chemicals on wildlife
    vertebrates. Reviews of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 198:1-47.

    Bhattacharyya, S., P.L. Klerks, and J.A. Nyman. 2003. Toxicity to freshwater organisms from
    oils and oil spill chemical treatments in laboratory microcosms. Environmental Pollution
    122(2003): 205–215.

    Bibby, C.J. 1981. An experiment on the recovery of dead birds from the North Sea. Ornis
    Scandinavica 12: 261-265.

    Bibby, C.J., and C.S. Lloyd. 1977. Experiments to determine the fate of dead birds at sea.
    Biological Conservation 12: 295–309.

    BirdsandBlooms.com. 2010. Gulf Oil Spill Q&A: Ken Rosenberg, director of Conservation
    Science, Cornell Lab of Ornithology, answers questions about the Gulf oil spill. Available at:
    http://www.birdsandblooms.com/Birds/General/Gulf-Oil-Spill-Q-A

    Bowman, T. 2010. Climate change and the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. An information summary
    for informal educators, science interpreters, and the public. July 3, 2010. Accessed March 10,
    2011 at: http://www.bowmanglobalchange.com/pdf_downloads/BowmanGulf%20Spill%20and%20CC%20071610.pdf

    Burdeau, C. 2011. U.S. Geological Survey finds 2,000-year-old coral near BP Gulf well.
    Associated Press, March 31, 2011. Available at: http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oilspill/index.ssf/2011/03/usgs_finds_2000-year-old_coral.html

    Burger. A. E. 1993. Estimating the mortality of seabirds following oil spills: effects of
    volume. Marine Pollution Bulletin 26 (3): 140-143.

    Bynum, R. 2011. Some pelicans saved from Gulf of Mexico oil spill stick to new home in
    Georgia. Associated Press, April 1, 2011. Available at: http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oilspill/index.ssf/2011/04/some_rescued_gulf_pelicans_ret.html

    Carls, M. G., S. D. Rice, and J. E. Hose. 1999. Sensitivity of fish embryos to weathered crude oil:
    part I. Low-level exposure during incubation causes malformations, genetic damage, and
    mortality in larval pacific herring (Clupea pallasi). Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
    18:481-493.

    Center for Biological Diversity. 2011. Endangered Species Act listing petition for dwarf seahorse.
    April 6, 2011. Available at: http://biologicaldiversity.org/species/fish/dwarf_seahorse/index.html

    Center for Biological Diversity. 2010. Endangered Species Act listing petition for Atlantic bluefin
    tuna. May 24, 2010. Available at:
    http://biologicaldiversity.org/species/fish/Atlantic_bluefin_tuna/index.html

    Farren, L. and B. Blackburn. 2010. EPA May Not Force BP to Change Dispersants. ABC World
    News, May 21, 2010. Available at: http://abcnews.go.com/WN/epa-bpdispersants/story?id=10711367.

    Gillis, J. and L. Kaufman. After Oil Spills, Hidden Damage Can Last for Years. New York
    Times, July 17, 2010. Available at:
    http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/18/science/earth/18enviro.html?_r=2&partner=rss&emc=rss

    Graham, W.M., R.H. Condon, R.H. Carmichael, I.D’ambra, H.K. Patterson, L.J. Linn, and F.J.
    Hernandez. 2010. Oil carbon entered the coastal planktonic food web during the Deepwater
    Horizon oil spill. Environmental Research Letters 5 (2010): 045301 (6pp). doi:10.1088/1748-
    9326/5/4/045301.

    Hart, K.M., P. Mooreside, and L.B. Crowder. 2006. Interpreting the spatio-temporal patterns of
    sea turtle strandings: Going with the flow. Biological Conservation 129(2006): 283-290.

    Hatcher, A. I. and A. W. D. Larkum. 1982. The effects of short term exposure to Bass Strait crude
    oil and Corexit 8667 on benthic community metabolism in Posidonia australis beds Hook.F.
    dominated microcosms. Aquatic Botany 12:219-227.
    https://thediplomat.com/2013/01/the-new-prize-china-and-indias-rare-earth-scramble/

    Posted at May 21, 2020 07:13:52PM EST by Zoella Lin

    Citations

    Show

    Script: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HbGerH0s6Vi3z2uP7VowbZ-_qw6gWSAn/view?usp=sharing

    Posted at May 23, 2020 12:43:03AM EST by Allana Spears

    Citations

    Show

    Jacob Philip, March/2014, "GENERAL SITE SUITABILITY
    CRITERIA FOR NUCLEAR POWER STATIONS": https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML1218/ML12188A053.pdf

    Valerie Volcovici, DEcember/5/2016, "Trump advisors aim to privatize oil-rich Indian reservations":
    https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-tribes-insight/trump-advisors-aim-to-privatize-oil-rich-indian-reservations-idUSKBN13U1B1

    THADDEUS SWANEK, November/6/2018, "Cost of Nuclear Generation Reaches Nearly 10-Year Low": https://www.nei.org/news/2018/cost-of-nuclear-generation-reaches-10-year-low

    KATHERINE BAGLEY, November/10/2016, "At Standing Rock, A Battle Over Fossil Fuels and Land": https://e360.yale.edu/features/at_standing_rock_battle_over_fossil_fuels_and_land

    Dallas Goldtooth, January/9/2015, "
    This article is more than 5 years old
    Keystone XL would destroy our native lands. This is why we fight": https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jan/09/keystone-xl-would-destroy-native-lands-we-fight

    Emily Cassidy, February/7/2019, "There Were 137 Oil Spills In The US In 2018. See Where They Happened.": https://blog.resourcewatch.org/2019/02/07/there-were-137-oil-spills-in-the-us-in-2018-see-where-they-happened/

    Status

    This match has been completed. Show the Decision.

    Submitted at May 24, 2020 04:55:21AM EST by Brittney Bleyle

    Category Allana Spears Zoella Lin
    Use of evidence: 4.5 6
    Delivery skill: 4.5 4.7
    Coherence of arguments: 4.3 4.8
    Responsiveness to opponent: 2.5 4.8
    Identification of key points: 3 4.1
    Comments: I think you have a great speaking style and are very clear and confident sounding. I'm not sure if you were just asking your opponent to slow down, or if you were wanting to put it forth as an framing argument and reason to reject the opposition; however, if it was the latter, you need to make sure to include it in your timed speech as well as impacting it out more and framing it as an a priori issue. I think that your choice to ignore the misgendering arguments and just extend your arguments supporting your plan was not the best choice for a couple of reasons. Your opponent has framed the misgendering arguments as an a priori issue, and something that should come before anything else in the debate. You said that your opponent dropped all of your arguments, but it doesn't mean that you get full access to them. Your opponent chose to focus on an issue deemed more important than any of the other arguments put forth so far, which means you have to win either: A. that you didn't misgender your opponent B. That you did but I as a judge should not use that as a reason to vote you down and disregard the plan C. that your opponent also did something that you believe to be as egregious and harmful as misgendering, etc. You kind of just ignored the arguments and framing completely from the opposition rebuttal and closing. I understand that the misgendering was more than likely unintentional, but it is necessary to address since your opponent spent the vast majority of the time in the rebuttal/closing on this argument. Mistakes happen, and it isn't always an auto-lose situation just because you made a mistake. I'm not sure that I've ever seen someone quote Joe Schatz more in one round. He was my college debate coach, and considering that he wrote the aliens affirmative I ran as a novice, I'm not sure if this gives your evidence more or less credibility. All jokes aside, I think you did very well. I'm happy to hear people are still reading to McGregor 03 card, it's a good card. I read it frequently. You slowed down your speed significantly after defending speed and spreading in this debate, and I'm not sure that this helps you considering that you just went for spreading good; it does help your clarity however, and so it might be something you want to do more frequently in this tournament going forward. I don't think you really *have* to spread when debating against people speaking at a casual pace, and this will avoid you having to spend time on defending the speed of your arguments. I hope that you don't have to have this misgendering argument going forward, because I hope people don't continue to misgender you in future debates; however, if it does happen again it might be helpful for you to say the timestamps of when they misgendered you. It's not super necessary, I could always rewatch the video myself if I didn't remember of course, but I do think it would be an additional effective and persuasive way of getting your point across. I think you did a great job at framing your argument as an a priori issue to anything else that has happened in the debate. I understand that I should vote your opponent down in order to send a message to the community and prevent further violence from people being misgendered; I am not clear still however as to why this means I need to give you 30s across the board. I could be persuaded I suppose, but I'm going to need a lot more of a reason. It feels like voting your opponent down is enough to send a message, and I'm not sure what giving you 30s on top of that will do further.

    The decision is for the Opposition: Zoella Lin

    Reason for Decision:

    I voted for the opposition. The proposition ends up misgendering the opposition, and the opposition spent almost all of the rebuttal/closing time explaining why this is so harmful, and why it is an a priori issue over anything else in the round. This wasn't really addressed sufficiently by the proposition, who continued to just reiterate the plan and the topic, and conceded the opposition's framework. At this point you have to win against the opposition's misgendering arguments first, and win the framing, before you can really bring up the plan/resolution again.Since it was conceded, I voted for the opponent's arguments about how misgendering is very violent, and in order to prevent it from frequently happening in the debate community, we need to send a signal by voting against teams that do it, whether intentional or not.


    Add Comment

    Please Create an Account or Log-In to post comments.

    Connect with Binghamton:
    Twitter icon links to Binghamton University's Twitter page YouTube icon links to Binghamton University's YouTube page Facebook icon links to Binghamton University's Facebook page Pinterest icon links to Binghamton University's Pinterest page

    Binghamton University Online Debate Platform powered by:

    PHP MySQL SUIT